Pinellas County Commissioner Chris Latvala was selected to serve as Chair of the Pinellas County Commission for 2027, with Commissioner Kathleen Peters ultimately securing the Vice Chair position following a contentious discussion that saw Commissioner René Flowers withdraw her name from consideration.
While Latvala’s selection was straightforward, the Vice Chair nomination sparked debate over the board’s leadership traditions, the demands of campaigning while serving as Chair, and Flowers’ repeated exclusion from leadership positions.
Commissioner Vince Nowicki initially nominated Commissioner Chris Scherer for Vice Chair, with Latvala seconding the motion.
But Peters and outgoing Chair Dave Eggers raised concerns about Scherer’s upcoming re-election campaign and freshman status (he was elected for the first time in 2024) in the commission.
Peters argued that taking on the “additional duty” of serving as Chair while running for office is difficult. Eggers, who recently secured re-election while serving as Chair, echoed that concern based on his own experience.
Instead, Peters voiced support for Flowers, a Democrat who represents southern Pinellas County and currently serves as President of the Florida Association of Counties, an organization representing all 67 Florida counties.
Flowers has also held leadership positions on the St. Petersburg City Council and Pinellas County School Board. But rather than embrace the nomination, Flowers expressed frustration that her colleagues had repeatedly passed her over for leadership positions, and despite Peters motioning for Flowers, the majority of the commission did not follow suit.
“I appreciate Peters throwing my hat in the ring, but this will be the fourth time I’m saying that I don’t want anything that no one thinks I deserve,” Flowers said.
She pointed to her recent election as President of the Florida Association of Counties as recognition of her leadership abilities outside the Commission.
“Yes, I have been blessed to become president of Florida Association of Counties, and maybe that was God’s way of giving me a gift when I did not get selected by my colleagues for a leadership role here,” Flowers said.
Flowers also challenged the argument that campaigning while serving as Chair should disqualify a Commissioner from consideration.
She recalled serving consecutive terms as Chair of the St. Petersburg City Council while actively campaigning for office, as well as balancing similar responsibilities during her time on the Pinellas County School Board.
She also pointed to the Commission’s previous decision to elevate Eggers to Vice Chair despite knowing he would likely assume the Chair position during his own re-election year.
For Flowers, the concerns raised about Scherer’s potential candidacy underscored what she viewed as an inconsistent approach to selecting the board’s leadership.
“I will dutifully remove my name,” Flowers said, acknowledging that she did not believe she had enough support from her colleagues to secure the position.
“I can read the tea leaves. I don’t have the votes,” she added. “Even if people here don’t think I deserve a leadership role here, there are others that will.”
Commissioners Tim Hughes and Peters both indicated they would have supported Flowers had she remained in consideration.
The discussion then returned to Scherer’s nomination, which failed after receiving just three votes. Scherer defended his interest in the position, stating that the imminent county budget and the financial challenges facing Pinellas following the passage of amendment three, which will squeeze the budget, are his bailiwick.
Following the failed vote, Flowers nominated Peters for Vice Chair, and the Commission approved her selection.
Peters, who won re-election earlier this month, said she had not actively sought a leadership position but was willing to serve. She also indicated that her new four-year term would likely be her last.
The leadership selections come as the Commission welcomes Hughes, a Democrat who defeated Republican incumbent Brian Scott for the countywide District 2 seat, narrowing the Commission’s Republican majority from 6-1 to 5-2. Flowers and Hughes are the two Democrats.
