The St. Petersburg City Council rejected a proposal Thursday that would bar officers in neighborhood associations from serving on the city’s Development Review Commission (DRC) and Community Planning and Preservation Commission (CPPC). The proposal was withdrawn after ferocious backlash from neighborhood leaders and the Council of Neighborhood Associations (CONA).

The change was proposed as part of the City’s larger annual review of Land Development Regulations. As state and federal laws, regulations, and building codes shift each year, St. Pete’s own regulations require amendments to maintain consistency. The City’s Planning Department, working with legal staff, packages together these revisions.

In proposing the ban, City staff noted that Commissioners serving on neighborhood boards “was historically discouraged as a condition of appointment to these two (2) Commissions to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest, especially when the neighborhood associations are engaged on a specific application and submit an official position to the Commission or City Council.”

Nevertheless multiple appointees held or were considered for such roles. Neighborhood boards, like the DRC and CPCC, are unpaid.

St. Pete’s DRC is a board of volunteer citizens who “review and evaluate proposed modifications to the Land Development Regulations,” according to the City. “The DRC acts as the Design Review Board and evaluates and acts on the development proposals within the City in order to ensure compliance with the Comprehensive Plan, zoning ordinance, and other appropriate City regulations.” If a project requires a zoning change, or an exception to a regulation such as a height restriction or setback from the street, it goes before the DRC.

The CPCC, meanwhile, deals with “reviewing map amendments to the Future Land Use and Official Zoning maps, text amendments to the Comprehensive Plan, participating in other specialized zoning and land use planning projects, and reviewing all matters pertaining to historic and archaeological preservation.”

If a developer or owner wishes to change a historic structure, or build something outside what’s foreseen in the City’s Comprehensive Plan, the CPCC weighs in.

Both Commissions’ decisions can be appealed to the City Council. A notable instance was Council’s reversal of the CPCC’s decision against the expansion of the 4th Street Chick-Fil-A, which will displace several residents and local businesses.

Board members from Historic Roser Park, Historic Uptown, Riviera Bay and Holiday Park Neighborhoods, among others, wrote letters or attended to speak against the proposed rule change, as did CONA President Franklin Alves. Faced with the pushback, Councilmembers struck the change from the proposed Land Development Regulations.

“Things shouldn’t go and be placed in an ordinance that prevent people from serving on a board,” Council Chair Lisset Hanewicz told Poliverse. “There are other ways that the underlying issue may be able to be addressed.”

CONA President Alves, in his own statement, expressed his relief at the decision but noted the irony that neighborhood volunteers had to spend the day ensuring their continued ability to volunteer.

“Our neighborhood leaders give what little free time they have to making St. Petersburg a better place,” said Alves. “They organize their neighbors, advocate for safer streets, and work toward complete, walkable communities where people can access the things they need to live a dignified life.

“Yet too often, those aspirations run into policies and codes that make them difficult to achieve. And today, we were confronting a proposal that would have further limited those residents’ ability to participate in shaping those decisions.

“I am grateful that City Council recognized this contradiction and voted to remove the proposed exclusion. But I hope today’s discussion encourages some deeper reflection about how we value civic engagement.

“We cannot continue to celebrate residents for giving their time to improve their neighborhoods while simultaneously creating barriers to their participation or maintaining policies that work against the very communities we’re asking them to help build.”