The Pinellas County Commission publicly conducted its performance review of County Administrator Barry Burton in a working session Thursday. Burton, the appointed head of Pinellas County Government since 2018, is set to continue in his role after obtaining broad support across the Commission.
During his tenure Burton has steered the County through Covid, and Hurricanes Helene and Milton; he will now take on the task of finding tens of millions of savings across County budgets following the passage of Amendment 3, which will slash millions in property taxes from municipal budgets.
Some of those will come from Burton’s own salary – he agreed prior to the review that he would not accept a pay raise for the coming year. Burton and Commissioners alike have received criticism at the rapid increase in Pinellas County’s operating budget since 2019, with Burton himself singled out over his $315,000 annual salary.
Incoming Chair Commissioner Chris Latvala (R–Clearwater) praised Burton for foregoing an agreed pay rise, while noting that Pinellas has to compete against the market. “If and when we look at a new Administrator, we’re not going to get a very good one for $150,000 a year. They’re going to want to get paid comparable to what County Administrators get paid.”
“There are nonprofit CEOs that have a fraction of the budget with a fraction of the employees that we have that make more than Barry Burton makes.”
Burton received broad approval for his work from Latvala and Commissioners Dave Eggers (R–Dunedin), Rene Flowers (D–St. Petersburg), and Kathleen Peters (R–Treasure Island).
But the opinion was not unanimous. Commissioner Vince Nowicki (R–St. Petersburg), who has frequently clashed with Burton and County Administration, called for a change of leadership.
“The passage of Amendment 3 has revealed a fundamental disconnect between the direction voters want and the taxing and spending approach the Administration has recommended,” Nowicki said.
“Before putting valuable public resources on the chopping block, we should be challenging administrative overhead, organizational structure, and spending that has become accepted simply because it was approved in previous years.”
“I believe it is time to establish the County Administrator’s retirement timeline and allow this Board to select new leadership.”
Commissioner Chris Scherer (R–St. Petersburg) praised Burton’s leadership but asked for a transition plan in 2027, noting that Burton had previously spoken of retirement and his concerns that staff didn’t take seriously previous pushes to downsize county administration. However, Scherer stopped short of directly calling for Burton to go.
They drew a heated reply from Peters. “When you say we don’t downsize or we haven’t been conservative enough, you haven’t looked at many counties in Southeast Florida,” she said.
“Barry’s job is to take direction from the majority of this Board,” she continued. “He’s got to do what the majority of his bosses say, not one individual Commissioner.”
“I have confidence in Barry’s ability to do what we tell him,” Eggers agreed. “I think our residents have spoken, and I am on board with bringing in smaller government. I think Barry has earned the right to continue working here. I have no interest in looking at any changes from my perspective.”
Flowers, while supporting Burton, criticized the evaluation process. “I don’t like that we’re doing this publicly. I don’t. I’ve worked in the human resources field for over 30 years. I have never done this with a President or CEO.
“I don’t want the public to think that Amendment 3 determined the County was going in the wrong direction,” she continued. “People said they wanted a reduction in property tax, not that they wanted a reduction in services.”
Burton will now have the opportunity – and responsibility – to deliver that reduction. Thanking the commissioners for their “broad support,” he committed himself to that task.
“Obviously the people have spoken. They passed Amendment 3. We, as a team, which includes this Commission and the Administration, have to come up with a plan to best reflect the priorities with limited resources. And I have been through that before.
“So the staff is prepared, they’re prepared to step forward… and make those hard decisions.”
